bg
  • Dela
Published: September 8th, 2009

germany-anti-nuclear-protest

This past weekend around 50 000 people from around Germany protested in Berlin against nuclear energy. The demonstrators protested against threats from the current right wing government to extend a deadline for the country’s 17 nuclear reactors.

“In Berlin an estimated 50,000 people have joined a demonstration against nuclear power in the run-up to the German general elections.

The rally was headed by a convoy of 350 tractors, which drove past the office of Chancellor Angela Merkel,” Radio Netherlands Worldwide reports.

Back in 2001 the former Social Democratic chancellor, backed up by the Greens, pushed through a new legislation in 2001 that would phase out nuclear energy from Germany within two decades. But the Social Democratic and Green government lost the election in 2005 to a right-wing coalition consisting of the current Chancellor Angela Merkel’s center-right Christian Democrats and the liberal Free Democrats.

Angela Merkel, who successfully blocked a strong climate deal for the European Union last year, now wants to scrap the nuclear phase-out legislation that the SPD pushed through in 2001. This is similar to what is happening in Sweden after a coalition of right-wing parties won the recent election there. According to Merkel, Germany “cannot phase out nuclear energy as quickly as some imagine.”

“But in the long term, that’s to say in the second half of the century, we will experience a large amount of renewable energy sources. We are convinced that we will be able to stop using nuclear energy at some point”, Merkel said.

The Social Democratic chancellor candidate, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, is accusing Angela Merkel’s center-right Christian Democrats and the liberal Free Democrats “of leading the country into an energy policy dead-end and endangering domestic security.”

germany-anti-nuclear-protest-2

On the same day as the anti-nuclear protest in Germany were taking place Greenpeace released a survey which found that 59% of Germans are against Merkel’s proposal to extend the deadline for the country’s already aging nuclear reactors.

“Our responsibility is to phase out power plants that endanger the health and livelihoods of future generations, said Greenpeace Finland’s nuclear campaigner, Lauri Myllyvirta at a speech the Brandenburg Gate.

“Each year nuclear power plants are kept running means more nuclear waste, more uranium mining, higher risk of accidents. There is no excuse: Climate change can be best tackled without nuclear plants. The nuclear phase-out in Germany is one of the reasons for the success of wind and solar energy all over the world. A relapse into nuclear power in Germany would send a very bad signal to other countries.”

Nils Diedrich, a political scientist at Berlin’s Free University, says that if Merkel and her right wing coalition manage to push through this pro-nuclear legislation “we’ll see a real battle”. He warns that “then there will be massive demonstrations.”

Although Germany is one of the leading countries in renewable wind energy it still has a dirty and toxic energy portfolio. 42% of the country’s energy comes from coal and 23% from nuclear energy. Only about 15% of the energy comes from clean renewable energy sources such as wind and solar.

Images from the Gruene.de

Simon Leufstedt
Simon Leufstedt is the founder and editor of Green Blog – an environment blog with authors from around the world. He is also the admin of Enviro Space - a place to meet, discuss and interact with other people who share your interests and ideas. Simon has previously studied Global Environmental Justice and is currently busy working with the Swedish TckTckTck organisation and learning everything there is to know about Human Ecology at the Lund University in Sweden.
Advertisement

Related Posts

Advertisement
RSS

Subscribe to Green Blog

Green Blog has daily updates and posts from authors around the world. Get our latest posts, commentaries and articles by RSS-feed or by adding your Email to our newsletter.

Learn More

This blog post has been marked with the following tags. Click on one of the tags to learn more:

You can also learn more about this topic by browsing the post's category: Business & Politics

Archives

Browse our archive of over +2 years worth of blog posts, articles and commentaries:

bg
bg

Comment Guideline

Comments with profanity, personal attacks or objectionable material will be edited or deleted. Feel free to refute someone's points or offer counter arguments, but please do not engage in name calling.

You can also customize your links and add some photos to your comments. Green Blog supports the following HTML tags: <a>, <b>, <i>, <u>, <em>, <p>, <blockquote>, <br>, <strong>, <strike>, <img>

We will show Disqus avatars and/or Gravatars next to your name.

  • Nuclear energy, especially in its current state, is underdeveloped when taking the environment into account. Solar energy is the way to go.

    For more info regarding solar energy, have a look at this Green Journal.
  • There is something that critical thinkers should know about Gerhard Schroeder, the Social Democratic chancellor who negotiated the deal to shut down Germany's 17 emission free nuclear power plants well before the end of their useful life.

    Within one month after he lost in his reelection bid to Ms. Merkel, he accepted a high level position with Gazprom, the Russian natural gas monopoly, with the responsibility of directing the completion of a gas pipeline under the Baltic Sea directly from Russia to Germany. http://bit.ly/ss8Qo

    The gas that the pipeline will carry will be used as part of the replacement power generation capacity. So will the biofuels produced by the farmers who led the protests in Berlin. Both gas and biofuels would have a smaller market at a lower price if the nuclear plants were kept in service.

    The dispute is not just about illogical fear of the potential consequences of a nuclear plant accident, it is also about a logical - if slightly immoral - desire to make money by selling goods that would not be needed if the useful plants were not prematurely removed from service. People motivated by greed are apparently is winning the hearts and minds of Germans, even though the result will be that they will pay higher prices for dirtier electricity than they would if the plants kept running.
  • "Within one month after he lost in his reelection bid to Ms. Merkel, he accepted a high level position with Gazprom, the Russian natural gas monopoly, with the responsibility of directing the completion of a gas pipeline under the Baltic Sea directly from Russia to Germany."
    Yes you are correct. And in my opinion that was morally wrong.

    But that doesn't take away the fact that Nuclear energy is Expensive, Dangerous, Not Cost-Effective and Will Worsen Climate Change. Simply put: nuclear power is not the answer to our energy and climate crisis.
  • Simon - the facts do not back up your assertions. Even your links are to documents that talk about the cost of future plants - which is a topic ripe for endless discussion because no one knows how much they might cost. That a debate topic where anyone is allowed to assert almost anything, after all, it is about the future.

    When it comes to a discussion about keeping 17 well built, well operated EXISTING nuclear plants running until they are at the end of their useful lives, the discussion about cost is something entirely different. According to page 39 of a book titled "Risks and benefits of nuclear energy" (available on Google Books with a very complex link) here are the costs of various forms of electricity in Germany in 2003 in euro cents per kilowatt-hour:
    Lignite - 3.3
    Hard coal - 3.0
    Oil - 3.1
    Gas - 3.6
    Nuclear - 2.1
    Hydro - 7
    Wind - 7
    Solar PB - 60 (that is right, sixty cents per kilowatt hour!)

    These costs come from actual accounting data on real plants. They are not figments of someone's imagination or predictions of the future.

    My reason for introducing Schroeder's betrayal into the discussion is that it should cause one to question why he was so adamant about shutting down those already constructed plants. Causing a market demand for Russian natural gas at a time when he might have been negotiating in private for a lucrative private position after "serving" as Chancellor just might be a logical explanation for his actions, especially when you find out just how greedy he was for personal wealth and status symbols.

    Say what you will about future nuclear plants; it is hard to assert that the existing ones are expensive to run or cause greenhouse gas emission. Heck, there are some places where governments have threatened to slap a windfall profits tax on nuclear electricity generators because they are so profitable when selling electricity in a competitive market whose price is set by natural gas or in a market where coal plants have to purchase emissions credits.
  • dennis
    One correction: Actually the Social Democratic Party still shares power with Angela Merkel's conservative party. So there is no conservative coalition in Germany. I am afraid that there will be after the elections on 9/27.
blog comments powered by Disqus
bg
bg
Twitter Bird

    Sustainability: A renewed look at locality in architecture

    By Job Mouwen on February 5th, 2010

    Photo credit: Jeremy Levine Design
    Sustainability has never reached the point where it became so imminent as it is nowadays and at the same time so unperfected in the architectural discussion. We are on the eve of an architectural revolution where situational design parameters are no longer used as a design tool to “catch” the [...]

    We must go from capitalism to socialism to tackle climate change, says Hugo Chavez

    By Simon Leufstedt on February 5th, 2010

    In an interesting interview during COP15 Amy Goodman from Democracy Now asks Hugo Chavez, President of Venezuela, about his view of the climate summit in Copenhagen, climate change, USA, and the huge oil reserves in Venezuela. Watch it:

    “AMY GOODMAN: What level of emissions are you willing to support reductions of emissions?
    PRESIDENT HUGO CHAVEZ: [translated] [...]

    Climate Racism, Climate Injustice & Copenhagen Greenhouse Gas Reduction Proposals

    By Dr Gideon Polya on February 4th, 2010

    “What can decent people do to save the Planet from the Australian, EU and US climate criminals?”
    The bottom line in the Copenhagen Climate Summit should be (a) equal per capita greenhouse gas emissions for everyone and (b) an additional but equitable penalty for First World countries for their disproportionately huge historical contribution to atmospheric carbon [...]

    Green Resolutions

    By Leah Karpus on January 30th, 2010

    Photo credit: woodleywonderworks
    Chances are, you already do quite a few of these already. These ideas certainly aren’t new or ingenious. However, they are simple, easy and attainable. So if you see something new on the list, give it a go. There are always things we can work on.
    Your Two New Best Friends…
    …are your reusable [...]

    Ice, snow, so where’s the global warming?

    By People's World on December 20th, 2009

    Photo credit: laszlo-photo
    As winter weather hits us again, many people confuse the current weather (cold) with the long-term direction of the climate (warmer).
    Just because it is cold outside right now doesn’t mean that global warming isn’t real. Global warming has to do with the climate, with the long-term trend of the world’s average temperature. [...]

    World leaders apologizes for climate failure in Copenhagen ads

    By Simon Leufstedt on December 20th, 2009

    Our world leaders haven’t yet apologized for their climate failure in Copenhagen so Greenpeace and the global tcktcktck campaign have done it for them in these advertisements at the Copenhagen airport:

    “I’m sorry,” the text of the ad reads. “We could have stopped catastrophic climate change… We didn’t.”
    Some of the so called world “leaders” depicted are [...]

    Watch Hugo Chavez: Capitalism is the way to the destruction of the planet

    By Simon Leufstedt on December 19th, 2009

    Yesterday Hugo Chavez, President of Venezuela, made a passionate and courageous speech at the UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen. Chavez criticized President Obama’s “laughable” promise to help climate change and also said that capitalism will destroy our planet. Watch it:

    Scratching the surface

    By Jonathan Sundqvist on December 17th, 2009

    I was listening to the pressconference that the European Union had the last two days. One would think that by now with all the high level people attending that they would have a clear and effective communication on what they want to achieve here in Copenhagen. More often than not the devil is in the [...]

    Naomi Klein: We want a good deal. And that’s what tomorrows demonstration is going to be about.

    By Simon Leufstedt on December 15th, 2009

    Naomi Klein speaking at the Klimaforum09 in Copenhagen.
    Tomorrow morning another large and important demonstration will be held in Copenhagen. This time the Climate Justice Action network is organizing a huge non-violent demonstration where the demonstrators are planning to march into the Bella Center, where the climate talks are being held. At the same time concerned [...]

    The “Danish text” makes developing nations furious and Naomi Klein says the deal we really need is not even on the table

    By Simon Leufstedt on December 8th, 2009

    Photo credit: adopt a negotiator
    Here are some of the biggest and most interesting news today related to the ongoing COP15 climate conference in Copenhagen:
    A draft text for a potential final agreement in Copenhagen was leaked today to the Guardian. The “Danish text” has made the developing countries “furious” as the draft agreement would give [...]

    Advertisement

    Latest Comments

    Latest Forum Topics

    Green Blog on Reddit

    Green Blog ♥ Reddit

    bg
    bg
    Powered by WordPress. Green Blog is licensed under a Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike license.
    Creative Commons License
    bg